Evaluating the clinical significance of color stability in nanohybrid composite resins: a comparative study of local and international brands

Hatice Tepe; Özge Çeliksöz; Batucan Yaman

Article Details

Evaluating the clinical significance of color stability in nanohybrid composite resins: a comparative study of local and international brands

Authors:

Hatice Tepe | Özge Çeliksöz | Batucan Yaman

Publisher:

MediHealth Academy Yayıncılık

Main Topics:

Restoratif Diş Tedavisi

Journal:

Journal of Health Sciences and Medicine Vol.7 Issue 5, pp.571-580

Document Type:

Article

Publication Date:

9/2024

Document Language:

English

Document ID (Org No.):

2001328465

pISSN:

2636-8579

Keywords:

Abstract:

 Aims: The objective of this study was to evaluate the color stability of five nanohybrid composite resins, including locally produced Turkish brands and an international brand, after exposure to staining and brushing simulations over time. Methods: Five nanohybrid composite resins; Filtek Z550 FLT, Dolgunn DLG, RubyComp Nano CMP, Nova Compo C NVC, and Parion PRN were tested. Specimens underwent staining and brushing simulations designed to replicate clinical oral conditions. The staining process involved immersing the specimens in a coffee solution for 8 hours per day over a 10-day period to simulate short-term staining t1, and for 12 days to simulate long-term staining equivalent to 1 year t2. Brushing cycles were used to replicate the mechanical wear caused by daily oral hygiene practices. Color measurements were recorded at baseline t0, after 10 days of staining t1, and after 1 year of simulated staining and brushing t2. Additional analyses were conducted using Energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy EDX and Scanning Electron Microscopy SEM to investigate structural and surface characteristics. Statistical analysis was performed using generalized linear models and two-way robust ANOVA to assess the significance of differences in color stability, with a significance level set at p0.05. Results: The main effect of the composite was not found to be statistically significant on the median ΔE values p0.078. The main effect of time was found to be statistically significant on the median ΔE values p0.001. Additionally, the interaction between composite and time was statistically significant on the median ΔE values p0.001. The highest median value of 3.12 was observed in the NVC composite from ΔE2, while the lowest median value of 1.285 was observed in the PRN composite from ΔE1. EDX and SEM analyses provided insights into the material compositions and their influence on color stability. Conclusion: The findings suggest that locally produced Turkish nanohybrid composites offer competitive color stability, making them viable alternatives to international brands for aesthetic dental restorations. This study highlights the need to consider both local and international materials for their clinical performance and cost-effectiveness in restorative dentistry. Future research should explore the long-term performance and clinical implications of these materials further.

 Aims: The objective of this study was to evaluate the color stability of five nanohybrid composite resins, including locally produced Turkish brands and an international brand, after exposure to staining and brushing simulations over time. Methods: Five nanohybrid composite resins; Filtek Z550 FLT, Dolgunn DLG, RubyComp Nano CMP, Nova Compo C NVC, and Parion PRN were tested. Specimens underwent staining and brushing simulations designed to replicate clinical oral conditions. The staining process involved immersing the specimens in a coffee solution for 8 hours per day over a 10-day period to simulate short-term staining t1, and for 12 days to simulate long-term staining equivalent to 1 year t2. Brushing cycles were used to replicate the mechanical wear caused by daily oral hygiene practices. Color measurements were recorded at baseline t0, after 10 days of staining t1, and after 1 year of simulated staining and brushing t2. Additional analyses were conducted using Energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy EDX and Scanning Electron Microscopy SEM to investigate structural and surface characteristics. Statistical analysis was performed using generalized linear models and two-way robust ANOVA to assess the significance of differences in color stability, with a significance level set at p0.05. Results: The main effect of the composite was not found to be statistically significant on the median ΔE values p0.078. The main effect of time was found to be statistically significant on the median ΔE values p0.001. Additionally, the interaction between composite and time was statistically significant on the median ΔE values p0.001. The highest median value of 3.12 was observed in the NVC composite from ΔE2, while the lowest median value of 1.285 was observed in the PRN composite from ΔE1. EDX and SEM analyses provided insights into the material compositions and their influence on color stability. Conclusion: The findings suggest that locally produced Turkish nanohybrid composites offer competitive color stability, making them viable alternatives to international brands for aesthetic dental restorations. This study highlights the need to consider both local and international materials for their clinical performance and cost-effectiveness in restorative dentistry. Future research should explore the long-term performance and clinical implications of these materials further.

 Aims: The objective of this study was to evaluate the color stability of five nanohybrid composite resins, including locally produced Turkish brands and an international brand, after exposure to staining and brushing simulations over time. Methods: Five nanohybrid composite resins; Filtek Z550 FLT, Dolgunn DLG, RubyComp Nano CMP, Nova Compo C NVC, and Parion PRN were tested. Specimens underwent staining and brushing simulations designed to replicate clinical oral conditions. The staining process involved immersing the specimens in a coffee solution for 8 hours per day over a 10-day period to simulate short-term staining t1, and for 12 days to simulate long-term staining equivalent to 1 year t2. Brushing cycles were used to replicate the mechanical wear caused by daily oral hygiene practices. Color measurements were recorded at baseline t0, after 10 days of staining t1, and after 1 year of simulated staining and brushing t2. Additional analyses were conducted using Energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy EDX and Scanning Electron Microscopy SEM to investigate structural and surface characteristics. Statistical analysis was performed using generalized linear models and two-way robust ANOVA to assess the significance of differences in color stability, with a significance level set at p0.05. Results: The main effect of the composite was not found to be statistically significant on the median ΔE values p0.078. The main effect of time was found to be statistically significant on the median ΔE values p0.001. Additionally, the interaction between composite and time was statistically significant on the median ΔE values p0.001. The highest median value of 3.12 was observed in the NVC composite from ΔE2, while the lowest median value of 1.285 was observed in the PRN composite from ΔE1. EDX and SEM analyses provided insights into the material compositions and their influence on color stability. Conclusion: The findings suggest that locally produced Turkish nanohybrid composites offer competitive color stability, making them viable alternatives to international brands for aesthetic dental restorations. This study highlights the need to consider both local and international materials for their clinical performance and cost-effectiveness in restorative dentistry. Future research should explore the long-term performance and clinical implications of these materials further.

 Aims: The objective of this study was to evaluate the color stability of five nanohybrid composite resins, including locally produced Turkish brands and an international brand, after exposure to staining and brushing simulations over time. Methods: Five nanohybrid composite resins; Filtek Z550 FLT, Dolgunn DLG, RubyComp Nano CMP, Nova Compo C NVC, and Parion PRN were tested. Specimens underwent staining and brushing simulations designed to replicate clinical oral conditions. The staining process involved immersing the specimens in a coffee solution for 8 hours per day over a 10-day period to simulate short-term staining t1, and for 12 days to simulate long-term staining equivalent to 1 year t2. Brushing cycles were used to replicate the mechanical wear caused by daily oral hygiene practices. Color measurements were recorded at baseline t0, after 10 days of staining t1, and after 1 year of simulated staining and brushing t2. Additional analyses were conducted using Energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy EDX and Scanning Electron Microscopy SEM to investigate structural and surface characteristics. Statistical analysis was performed using generalized linear models and two-way robust ANOVA to assess the significance of differences in color stability, with a significance level set at p0.05. Results: The main effect of the composite was not found to be statistically significant on the median ΔE values p0.078. The main effect of time was found to be statistically significant on the median ΔE values p0.001. Additionally, the interaction between composite and time was statistically significant on the median ΔE values p0.001. The highest median value of 3.12 was observed in the NVC composite from ΔE2, while the lowest median value of 1.285 was observed in the PRN composite from ΔE1. EDX and SEM analyses provided insights into the material compositions and their influence on color stability. Conclusion: The findings suggest that locally produced Turkish nanohybrid composites offer competitive color stability, making them viable alternatives to international brands for aesthetic dental restorations. This study highlights the need to consider both local and international materials for their clinical performance and cost-effectiveness in restorative dentistry. Future research should explore the long-term performance and clinical implications of these materials further.

Article Details

Evaluating the clinical significance of color stability in nanohybrid composite resins: a comparative study of local and international brands

Authors:

Hatice Tepe | Özge Çeliksöz | Batucan Yaman

Publisher:

MediHealth Academy Yayıncılık

Main Topics:

Restoratif Diş Tedavisi

Journal:

Journal of Health Sciences and Medicine Vol.7 Issue 5, pp.571-580

Document Type:

Article

Publication Date:

9/2024

Document Language:

English

Document ID (Org No.):

2001328465

pISSN:

2636-8579

Nanohybrid composite resin

color stability

staining simulation

brushing simulation

spectrophotometer

Issues

Article Details

Evaluating the clinical significance of color stability in nanohybrid composite resins: a comparative study of local and international brands

Authors: Hatice Tepe | Özge Çeliksöz | Batucan Yaman

Publisher: MediHealth Academy Yayıncılık

Main Topics: Restoratif Diş Tedavisi

Journal: Journal of Health Sciences and Medicine Vol.7 Issue 5, pp.571-580

Document Type: Article

Publication Date: 9/2024

Document Language: English

Document ID (Org No.): 2001328465

pISSN: 2636-8579

Nanohybrid composite resin

color stability

staining simulation

brushing simulation

spectrophotometer

Issues

Authors:

Hatice Tepe | Özge Çeliksöz | Batucan Yaman

Publisher:

MediHealth Academy Yayıncılık

Main Topics:

Restoratif Diş Tedavisi

Journal:

Journal of Health Sciences and Medicine Vol.7 Issue 5, pp.571-580

Document Type:

Article

Publication Date:

9/2024

Document Language:

English

Document ID (Org No.):

2001328465

pISSN:

2636-8579